Count your responses before you compare anything else
Response allowances decide most of the bill. Typeform's Basic plan allows 100 responses a month, while Tally's free plan has no cap within its fair use policy. At the limit, Jotform disables forms, Typeform makes them private, SurveyMonkey charges $0.15 per extra response and Fillout keeps collecting. Count people too. Fillout and Tally cover unlimited team members for one price, Typeform caps plans at 1, 3 or 5 users, Jotform's self-serve plans are single-user and SurveyMonkey bills per user.
Completion rate is worth real money on high-value forms
A finished lead form is worth more than an abandoned one. All five tools can show one question at a time: Typeform by default, Jotform and SurveyMonkey as a layout, Tally and Fillout with one question per page. Jotform recommends that style for short forms and its classic layout for long ones, so try both, and use the drop-off reports on Typeform Business, Fillout Business or Tally Pro to see where people quit.
Check compliance before collecting anything sensitive
Health data covered by HIPAA calls for a signed business associate agreement with the form vendor. Jotform includes one, with HIPAA features, on Gold at $129 a month or $99 billed yearly; SurveyMonkey offers HIPAA only on Enterprise, and Typeform signs BAAs for Enterprise and Growth Custom customers. Tally and Fillout document no HIPAA option. For EU hosting, Tally stores data in Europe and Jotform can move an account to Frankfurt; the other three offer it only on top-tier plans.
Where the data goes matters more than the form
A form is a way of getting data into another system, so check that the connection you need is native. Tally, Fillout and Typeform connect to Google Sheets and Airtable on their free plans. Zapier adds a second bill as volume grows. A Zap that adds each submission to a CRM and posts it in Slack uses two tasks, so 400 submissions a month exceed the 750 tasks in Zapier Professional, at $29.99 a month or $19.99 billed yearly. On Tally's or Fillout's free plan, that would be the team's only bill.